Short-term performance effects of caffeinated energy drinks in adults
The EFISZ review found short-term benefits in selected endurance, strength, attention and alertness outcomes in adults after the energy drinks studied. Findings depend on the drink, dose, participants, task and comparator; additional benefits beyond equivalent caffeine doses remain uncertain.
Selected numerical findings
| Evidence | Result | Scope |
|---|---|---|
| Review coverage | 17 controlled beverage trials and 7 evidence syntheses | A targeted international literature search; some trials also appear in the cited syntheses, so these are not independent participant counts. |
| Endurance meta-analysis | Standardised effect size 0.53 across 13 endurance comparisons | Reported by a meta-analysis of 34 studies; the effect size is not a percentage improvement. |
| Five-kilometre running trial | Mean completion time 2.1% shorter than placebo; 18 participants | A specific drink containing 160 mg caffeine in a controlled trial. |
| Cycling time trial | Mean completion time 4.7% shorter than placebo; 12 participants | A specific drink containing 160 mg caffeine in a separate controlled trial. |
Methods
The structured narrative review used a targeted international literature search and assessed results by outcome and comparator. It distinguished placebo comparisons from caffeine-matched comparisons and considered physical and cognitive performance, alertness and simulated driving.
Limitations
Most trials were small and often involved young or trained adults. Drinks, doses, controls and tasks differed. Some primary trials also appear in the syntheses; apparently consistent findings may therefore use overlapping data. Several trials received industry financial or product support, as identified in the original review.
Simulator findings do not establish a reduction in real-world crash risk. Short follow-up and inconsistent reporting of physiological changes and symptoms limit conclusions about safety. In caffeine-matched comparisons, added benefits from the other ingredients remain uncertain.
Interpretation
Benefits in particular short-term tasks cannot automatically be generalised to every energy drink, consumer or use. The results do not establish that a whole drink is superior to the same dose of caffeine on its own.
Original review and references
Full original review and study tables (Hungarian, with an English abstract)